Matt Fatheree, co-owner of Hilltop Tavern, personally selected each piece of sports memorabilia on the walls. He owns the restaurant with his wife, Tiffany Fatheree. The concept for Hilltop Tavern arose from a desire to create a sports bar, following the opening of their previous restaurant, The Butcher's Cellar.

The Fatherees aimed to create a more relaxed, family-friendly atmosphere at Hilltop Tavern. According to Tiffany, there was a need for such a venue in the area, where people could watch sports in a casual setting.

Further details about Hilltop Tavern can be found through the source, including its opening and more information about the restaurant's concept and atmosphere.